About this tool
This tool applies four pediatric head CT decision rules other than PECARN: CATCH from Canada, CHALICE from the UK, the pediatric analysis of NEXUS II and the UC Davis (Palchak) rule. It is for clinicians who work with one of these rules locally, or who want to compare them with PECARN, which has its own tool.
Pick the rule first. A child with GCS 12 or less or a penetrating injury goes straight to CT and neurosurgery. Then answer the rule's entry and risk questions one step at a time: CATCH checks entry findings, four high-risk and three medium-risk factors; CHALICE asks history, examination (with infant thresholds under 1 year) and mechanism; NEXUS II asks seven findings; UC Davis asks five predictors, with scalp haematoma counted only at 2 years or younger.
The result says CT recommended, consider CT (CT or observation for 4–6 hours from the injury) or CT not needed, with what to do next: neurosurgery for a bleed or depressed fracture, when to think of abuse, discharge and return advice. Each result gives the rule's accuracy in its own study, and a note that PECARN was the most sensitive rule in the 2017 Australia and New Zealand comparison (Babl, Lancet). Sources: Osmond, CMAJ 2010; Dunning, Arch Dis Child 2006; Oman, Pediatrics 2006; Palchak, Ann Emerg Med 2003; Babl, Lancet 2017.
Common questions
Which pediatric head CT rule is best?
In the largest head-to-head study (20,137 children in Australia and New Zealand, Babl 2017), PECARN had the highest sensitivity: 100% under 2 years and 99.0% at 2 years or older for clinically important brain injury. CATCH was 95.2% for need for neurological intervention and CHALICE 92.3%. All had negative predictive values above 99%. Most US and Australian guidance uses PECARN.
What are the CATCH high-risk factors?
GCS below 15 two hours after the injury, a suspected open or depressed skull fracture, a history of worsening headache, and irritability on examination. The medium-risk factors are signs of basal skull fracture, a large boggy scalp haematoma, and a dangerous mechanism (motor vehicle crash, fall from 3 ft or 5 stairs, or a fall from a bicycle without a helmet).
Who does CHALICE apply to?
Children under 16 with any head injury; loss of consciousness is not required. CT is advised if any history, examination or mechanism criterion is present. Under 1 year, GCS below 15 and a bruise, swelling or laceration larger than 5 cm also count.
Why is NEXUS II rarely used in children?
It was tested only in children who already had CT, and although it found 136 of 138 children with clinically important injury, it called only 230 of 1,666 low risk. It is very sensitive but not specific, so it would not reduce CT use much.